ASIS 95 Comments Summary
Last Update 17 December 1998
Com# Comment / Section Submitter Date Stat Ref
--- ------------------------------------------ ------------- -------- ---- ---
001 environ{n}ements et interfaces de logiciel A. Le Guennec 96-12-12 A
ASIS 95-Cover
002 Name replaced by Defining_Name_Image S. Rybin 97-01-21 A
ASIS 95-15.1, 15.2, 15.4
003 ASIS.Expressions: Value instead of S. Rybin 97-01-21 A
Value_Image and Name instead of
Defining_Name_Image
ASIS 95-17.1, 17.2
004 Element[ ]{_}Kinds J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 M
ASIS 95-Interface summary(1), line 5-6,9
005 Unit[ ]{_}Kinds J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 M
ASIS 95-Interface summary(1) line 10
006 permissions given a[ ]{n } J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-1.1.2(?) line 19
007 various typos J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
defines [one]{two} optional -- ASIS 95-1.1.3.1(?) line 34
[(with child]{and its child} -- ASIS 95-1.1.3.1(?) line 34
Portable_Transfer[)]{}. -- ASIS 95-1.1.3.1(?) line 35
008 identifies [three]{four} ASIS client J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-1.1.4.2(2) line 26
009 {Element tree for}[For] J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.1(?) figure 2-1
010 Asis[.Statements].A_Block_Statement J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 X
ASIS 95-2.2.3.1(?) page 16, line 5
011 will presumably {be }processed J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.1(?) page 16, line 14
012 a loop [indication]{iteration} J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.3(1) line 42
013 onto one [of]{or} more J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.3(?) page 21, line 4
014 terminology J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.2.1(1) line 17-18
015 terminology J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 M
ASIS 95-2.2.3.1(1) line 39-40
016 constant J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.3(1) line 44
017 description of package ASIS J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 M
ASIS 95-2.3(2) line 12-14
018 number of contexts J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.3(?) page 21, line 1-8
019 using a context before open J. Jorgensen 97-02-09 A
ASIS 95-2.4.3(?) line 30-31
020 The Ada [program]{lexical} element J. Jorgensen 97-02-16 A
ASIS 95-3.8(1) line 58
021 don't refer to old ASIS versions J. Jorgensen 97-02-16 A
ASIS 95-6.4(1) line 35
022 illegal Ada J. Jorgensen 97-02-16 A
ASIS 95-3.11.1(3) line 41
023 Wrong use of Ada term J. Jorgensen 97-02-16 A
ASIS 95-6.6(4)
024 remove section 1.1.4.5 D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-1.1.4.5
025 remove section 1.1.4.6 D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-1.1.4.6
026 Mapping between ASIS.Errors D. Smith 97-02-22 A
and ASIS.Exceptions
ASIS 95-1.1.5 Classification of Errors
027 Complete definition of exceptions D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-1.1.5 Classification of Errors
028 typo D. Smith 97-02-22 A 013
ASIS 95-2.3 ASIS package aritecture
029 Move declaration of Traverse_Control D. Smith 97-02-22 X
ASIS 95-3.15
030 Full Path name needed for Put in D. Smith 97-02-22 A
Asis_Application_Example
ASIS 95-ss.ss(pp)
031 Insert Array Reference D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-B.2
032 Correct path for Element_Kinds D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-B.2
033 Correct type reference for Unit_Name D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-B.3
034 Add use type declaration D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-B.3
035 Add full pathname for A_Selected_Component D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-B.3
036 Change "Full_Image_Name" to D. Smith 97-02-22 A
"Full_Name_Image"
ASIS 95-B.3
037 mispelling D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95-C
038 Remove irrelevent part of standard D. Smith 97-02-22 M
ASIS 95-C.3 Implementation approach for IDL
Commercially available automatic IDL generators
ASIS 95-C.3
039 The phrase, "the child package" D. Smith 97-02-22 X
ASIS 95
040 Use ASIS instead of Asis D. Smith 97-02-22 M
ASIS 95
041 Remove the word "actual" D. Smith 97-02-22 A
ASIS 95
042 The International Standard is called Ada, M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
not Ada 95
ASIS 95
043 dependenc[i]es M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
ASIS 95-1.1.3.1(5)
044 in that i[s]{t} uses M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
ASIS 95-1.1.3.3.3
045 for a Basi[s]{c} Conforming M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
ASIS 95-1.1.3.3.3
046 [three]{four} M. Pickett 97-02-27 A 008
ASIS 95-1.1.4.2(2)
047 abstraction[,] which M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
ASIS 95-2.1.2(3)
048 presumably {be} processed M. Pickett 97-02-27 A 011
ASIS 95-2.2.3.1(7)
049 List{s} of elements are M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.3(1)
050 Asis.Text.{Last_}Line_Number (20.9) M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.4
051 mapped onto one o[f]{r} more implementor M. Pickett 97-02-27 A 013
ASIS 95-2.3(4)
052 Asis_Inappropriate_Context {if} the M. Pickett 97-02-27 A
Context value is not open
ASIS 95-2.4.4.1
053 dependenc[i]es J. Dawes 97-02-03 A 043
ASIS 95-1.1.3.1(3) And elsewhere e.g. 3.14.4
054 Please define 'RM' J. Dawes 97-02-03 A
ASIS 95-2.1.2(3)
055 implementation{-}defined J. Dawes 97-02-03 A
ASIS 95-2.1.2(4) and lots of other places.
056 will presumably {be} processed further J. Dawes 97-02-03 A 011
ASIS 95-2.2.3.1
057 into the environment.[.] J. Dawes 97-02-03 A
ASIS 95-10.1(9)
058 A_Nonexist[a]{e}nt_Declaration, or J. Dawes 97-02-03 A
A_Nonexist[a]{e}nt_Body.
ASIS 95-10.
059 the St{r}ing image J. Dawes 97-02-03 A
ASIS 95-13.40
060 Incorrect reference R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.4
061 Inconsistent section references R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-2.3
062 Organize the package hierarchy R. Price 97-03-07 M
ASIS 95-2.3
063 Ada LRM citations should be more distinct R. Price 97-03-07 A 054
ASIS 95-3.11.2 to 23
064 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-3.11.2
065 Incorrect cross reference R. Price 97-03-07 M 054
ASIS 95-2.2.3.1
066 Confusing Ada RM section reference R. Price 97-03-07 M 054
ASIS 95-3.11.5
067 Confusing Ada RM section reference R. Price 97-03-07 M 054
ASIS 95-3.11.5
068 Questionable reference R. Price 97-03-07 M
ASIS 95-3.11.6
069 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-3.11.10
070 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-3.11.10
071 Paragraph is difficult to understand R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-12.1
072 Incorrect spelling of string R. Price 97-03-07 A 059
ASIS 95-13.40
073 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-15.20
074 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-15.23
075 Move Asis.Ids from section 23 to 21 R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-23
076 Provide an index R. Price 97-03-07 A
ASIS 95-index
077 A_Private_Extension_Declaration can be S. Rybin 97-03-17 A
returned by Corresponding_Type_Declaration
ASIS 95-15.13
078 only in that i[s]{t} uses nonstandard A. Le Guennec 97-03-17 A
ASIS 95-1.1.3.3.4
079 accept[s] A_Type_Definition elements A. Le Guennec 97-03-17 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.2
080 or the Asis.Expressions package A. Le Guennec 97-03-17 A
(Section 17) that accept[s]
ASIS 95-2.2.3.2
081 Some functions return[s] a A. Le Guennec 97-03-17 A
ASIS 95-2.2.3.4
082 Its child package A. Le Guennec 97-03-17 A
Asis.Implementation.Permissions provide{s}
ASIS 95-2.3
083 The 'T' in 'Line. The logical' should not A. Le Guennec 97-03-17 A
be used in bold font
ASIS 95-Annex A
084 as they are support[o]{e}rs of Interface A. Le Guennec 97-03-17 A
Generics
ASIS 95-C.3.3
085 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-20 A
ASIS 95-16.17
086 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-20 A
ASIS 95-19.1
087 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-20 A
ASIS 95-19.3
088 Incorrect Ada RM references R. Price 97-03-20 A
ASIS 95-19.5
089 Annex D Suggested Corrections D. Cooper 97-03-31 A
090 typo A. Le Guennec 97-04-23 A
091 Changes based on ISO review J. Spangler 97-07-15 A
092 Usable index C. Colket 97-07-15 A
093 Editorial mistake Corresponding_Children A. Le Guennec 98-01-07 A
094 A_Predefined_Unit clarification S. Rybin 98-01-15 A
095 Editorial change Corresponding_Loop_Exited S. Rybin 98-01-15 A
096 Editorial change to Corresponding_Type S. Rybin 98-01-16 A
097 Editorial change to A. Le Guennec 98-01-22 A
Asis.Compilation_Units.Subunits
098 Editorial changes to function S. Rybin 98-01-30 A
Corresponding_Declaration
099 A list of returned kinds is missing S. Rybin 98-01-31 A
for Implicit_Inherited_Declarations
100 Formal_Parameter can return S. Rybin 98-02-06 A
An_Operator_Symbol
101 Figure 3, Semantic Reference Using V. Fofanov 97-11-11 A
Corresponding Queries, is incorrect
102 Extra returned Declaration_Kinds in list S. Rybin 98-01-30 A
103 Clarification regarding task types S. Rybin 98-02-06 A
104 Appendix B examples should replace use of B. Thomas 98-02-26 A
String type
105 typographical error in 3rd bullet of 2.4.3 JAPAN 98-03-17 A
106 Return of Wide_String vice Program_Text S. Blake 98-04-28 A
107 Missing mode indications in functions S. Rybin 98-04-29 A
108 Changes based on ISO review J. Spangler 98-04-30 A
109 Name should be Name_Image G. Barnes 98-10-06 A
110 Should Is_Dispatching_Operation be in S. Rybin 98-10-09 A
ASIS.Declarations package?
111 Additional appropriate kinds for G. Barnes 98-10-14 A
Digits_Expression
112 Additional appropriate kinds for G. Barnes 98-10-14 A
Delta_Expression
113 Additional appropriate kinds for G. Barnes 98-10-14 A
Real_Range_Constraint
114 Additional appropriate kinds for G. Barnes 98-10-14 A
Access_To_Object_Definition
115 Additional appropriate kinds for G. Barnes 98-10-14 A
Subtype_Mark
116 Requeue_Entry_Name description G. Barnes 98-10-14 A
117 Is_Dispatching_Call list labeled wrong G. Barnes 98-10-14 A
118 Corresponding_Expression_Type has new case S. Rybin 98-08-15 A
for Nil_Element
119 Subunits returns Unit_Kinds which are not G. Barnes 98-12-07 A
subunits
120 Corresponding_Type returns G. Barnes 98-10-29 A
A_Formal_Type_Definition
121 Corresponding_Type_Operators parameter is G. Barnes 98-10-29 A
a formal type definition
122 Entries and Correponding_Declaration G. Barnes 98-12-07 M
/ Corresponding_Body
123 Corresponding_Type_Structure seems G. Barnes 98-11-11 A
incomplete
124 Corresponding_Body and pragma Import G. Barnes 98-12-08 A
125 A_Configuration_Compilation Unit_Kind G. Barnes 98-12-07 A
126 Generic child units of generic parents, G. Barnes 98-12-17 A
traversal questions
--- ------------------------------------------ ------------- -------- ---- ---
Com# Comment / Section Submitter Date Stat Ref
Com#: Comment Number
Comment / Section: Short explanatory version of the comment.
This may sometimes be on more than one line. Otherwise,
the second line is the appropriate section of the ASIS
ISO document. (Note that these may be in pairs.)
Submitter: Person who submitted comment.
Stat: Status may have one of the following letters:
N New comment semi-automatically entered into database
O Comment Open for review
M Comment approved with Modification
A Approved or Accepted
X Rejected; appropriate rationale also included
Date: Date that the comment was submitted
Ref: See also the comment with this Comment Number
Note: All approved Editorial Comments through C092 are incorporated
in version 2.0.P of the ASIS Working Draft.
Note: All Editorial Comments from C093 through C105 are a result of
the ISO SC22 Ballotting process. Comments C093 through C104 were
submitted with the US ballot; comment c105 was submitted with the
Japanese ballot. All these comments are incorporated in version
2.0.Q. After ASIS version 2.0.Q was reviewed, it was submitted as the
Draft International Standard (DIS) for the Final DIS (FDIS) ballot.
The resulting ASIS version 2.0.R was submitted as the FDIS to SC22 on
31 July 1998. During FDIS ballot, the document was proofed and
Editorial Comments starting with c109 resulted from this review.
Those with an Approved (A or M) status will be incorporated into ASIS.
Last update 17 December 1998. Questions, comments to Clyde Roby (CRoby@IDA.Org)