[Up] [SIGAda] [ACM]

ASIS 95 Issues Summary



                        ASIS 95 Issues Summary 

                     Last Update 17 December 1998

IS#            Title              Submitter    Section Stat Ver  Action
--- --------------------------- -------------- ------- ---- --- ---------
001 Proposed ASIS 95            S. Blake       ASIS     A    D  08-Mar-95 Email
    Element_Kind Type Hierarchy
002 Proposed changes to ASIS 83 S. Blake       STD      A    D  08-Mar-95 Email
    to product the ASIS 95
    draft standard
003 Traceability for            D. Rittersdorf STD      A    D  11-Mar-96
    outstanding ASIS 83 issues
004 Environment model           S. Rybin       STD      A    D  27-Jun-95 Email
    for ASIS 95
005 Proposed conformance rules  J. Lonjers     General  A    D  11-Mar-96
006 Unification between Element D. Ehrenfried  STD      X       08-Mar-95
    nodes and Compilation Unit
    nodes
007 Use stronger typing         C. Barbasch    STD      R       08-Mar-95
008 Flattening of node kinds    D. Ehrenfried  ASIS     X       27-Jun-95 Email
009 Don't preclude a            ASISWG         General  A    I  08-Mar-95 Email
    client/server ASIS
    implementation
010 Support of comments in      ASISWG/Europe  Text     A    E  08-Mar-95 Email
    Source Text
011 ASIS 83 Program Library =>  ASISWG         STD      A    E  12-Mar-96 Email
    ASIS 95 Compilation
    Environment
012 Terminology for ASIS 95     ASISWG         Gloss    A    J  03-Dec-96 Email
    Glossary
013 Don't preclude plug'n'play  ASISWG         General  A    J  03-Dec-96 Email
014 ASIS must be "tasking-safe" ISO WG9        General  A    K  03-Dec-96 Email
015 Context Clause error in     J. Barnes      Example  A    J  03-Dec-96 Email
    ASIS example
016 Place all ASIS interfaces   J. Barnes      STD      A    J  03-Dec-96 Email
    in ASIS or as child or ASIS
017 Remove Id's and             J. Joergensen  IDs      M    K  03-Dec-96 Email
    Id_Segment's from ASIS
018 Inconsistent subsets        S. Rybin       STD      M    K  03-Dec-96 Email
    in ASIS 95
019 Use deferred constant       S. Rybin       CU       M    K  03-Dec-96
    instead of function for
    Nil_Relationship
020 Control over Hash functions D. Rittersdorf Elem     X       03-Dec-96
021 Delete Family,              S. Rybin       ASIS     M    K  03-Dec-96
    Direct_Supporters, and
    Direct_Dependents
022 Normalize association list  S. Rybin       STD      M    K  03-Dec-96 Email
023 More definitions for        C. Roby        Gloss    A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Glossary
024 Class-wide types in ASIS    S. Rybin       Expr     M    M  25-Mar-97 Email
025 Root_Type_Kinds problem     S. Rybin       ASIS     A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
026 Eliminate Name homonym      S. Rybin       CU       M    M  25-Mar-97 Email
027 Corresponding_Name_-        S. Rybin       Expr     A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Definition
028 Clarification of function   S. Rybin       Text     M    M  28-May-97 Email
    Lines
029 String Images of            S. Rybin       Decl     A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Wide_Character literals
030 Corresponding_Expression_-  S. Rybin       Expr     A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Type for an attribute
    designator
031 Change name of              J. Jorgensen   Tech     A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Initial_Value query
032 Clarification on use of     J. Jorgensen   Tech     A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Asis.Ids
033 Corresponding_Declaration   J. Jorgensen   Decl     M    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    and Corresponding_Body
034 Upper bound for             J. Jorgensen   ASIS     A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Asis_Natural and Asis_Positive
035 Conventions for casing      J. Jorgensen   STD      A    M  25-Mar-97 Email
036 Mode_Kind return for access J. Jorgensen   Elem     M    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    parameter
037 Non testable requirements   D. Smith       General  M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
038 Implementation permission   D. Smith       General  M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    issues
039 Subtype declarations of     D. Smith       ASIS     A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    Asis_Character and Asis_String
040 Rename Compilation_Cpu_Time D. Smith       CU       A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
041 Example B.3 does not        D. Smith       Example  A    N  28-May-97 Email
    compile
042 Formal parameter naming     D. Smith       STD      X       26-Mar-97 Email
    conventions
043 Move type declarations to   D. Smith       ASIS     X       26-Mar-97 Email
    appropriate child packages
044 Arrays for lists need       D. Smith       STD      R       26-Mar-97 Email
    strong typing
045 Issues for acceptance of    D. Smith       STD      X       26-Mar-97 Email
    ASIS as standard
046 Confused purpose            M. Pickett     Front    M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
047 Paragraph and line numbers  J. Dawes       STD      R       23-May-97 Email
048 Sections no longer allowed  J. Dawes       STD      A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    by new ISO Directives
049 Usage of modal verbs        J. Dawes       STD      A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
050 Move CORBA section to       J. Dawes       General  M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    Annex C
051 Define "tasking-safe"       J. Dawes       General  M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
052 Consistent use of italics   J. Dawes       General  A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    for Glossary terms
053 Provide missing sentinels   J. Dawes       Def      A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
054 Queries having Context as   S. Rybin       CU       M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    additional parameter
055 Remove Enclosing_Generic    S. Rybin       Elem     A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
056 Rename Default_Kinds to     R. Price       ASIS     A    M  26-Mar-97
    Subprogram_Default_Kinds
057 Storage_Error as the name   S. Rybin       Error    X       26-Mar-97 Email
    used for Asis error status
058 Cases when semantic queries S. Rybin       Decl     A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    return results equal to
    arguments
059 Not_A_Clause cannot be      S. Rybin       Decl     A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    returned by
    Corresponding_Representation_Clauses
060 Text/String images for      S. Rybin       Decl     A    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    labels
061 Statement Labels            A. Le Guinnec  Decl     M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
062 Returned kinds for          S. Rybin       Def      M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    Corresponding_Parent_Subtype
    and Corresponding_Root_Type
063 Pragmas between two labels  A. Le Guinnec  Stmt     M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    attached to the same
    statement
064 Ada Wide_Character and      R. Price       STD      A    N  28-May-97 Email
    Wide_String
065 Body of a library           S. Rybin       CU       M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
    subprogram without separate
    specification
066 Root types and Universal    S. Rybin       STD      M    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    types in ASIS
067 Corresponding_Name_-        S. Rybin       Expr     M    M  25-Mar-97 Email
    Definition and renaming
    declarations
068 Format of document          J. Barnes      STD      M    M  26-Mar-97 Email
069 Clarification of            S. Rybin       Text     A    M  08-Apr-97
    Compilation_Unit_Span and
    Compilation_Span
070 Clarification to Lines      S. Rybin       Text     A    M  08-Apr-97
071 Corresponding_Called_Entity A. Le Guennec  ASIS     A    M  18-Apr-97
    and access to subprogram
    dereference
072 Pragma parameters           S. Rybin       Expr     A    M  18-Apr-97
073 Protected type/object is    S. Rybin       Decl     A    M  19-Apr-97
    missing as an argument for
    Corresponding_Body
074 Corresponding_Called_Entity A. Le Guennec  ASIS     R       28-May-97
    and dispatching calls
075 Description of              A. Le Guennec  CU       A    M  24-Apr-97
    Asis.Compilation_Units.Relations.Relationship
076 Protected type/object is    S. Rybin       Decl     A    N  23-May-97 Email
    missing as an argument for
    Corresponding_Declaration
077 Renaming-as-body and        S. Rybin       Decl     M    N  28-May-97 Email
    renaming-as-declaration
078 Corresponding_Base_Entity   S. Rybin       Decl     M    N  28-May-97 Email
079 Corresponding_Called_Entity A. Le Guennec  STD      M    N  28-May-97 Email
    and stream-oriented
    attribute references
080 Missed returned kind for    S. Rybin       Decl     A    P  25-Aug-97 Email
    Result Profile
081 Recursive calls of generic  S. Rybin       STD      A    P  25-Aug-97 Email
    subprograms
082 Categorization pragmas      R. Dewar       STD      A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
083 Normalized generic          S. Rybin       STD      A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
    association questions
084 Formal package parameters   A. Le Guennec  Decl     X       07-Jan-98 Email
    seen as instantiations
085 Is_Defaulted_Association    S. Rybin       Expr     A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
    Expected Kinds list
086 Also consider               A. Le Guennec  Decl     A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
    A_Formal_Package_Declaration{_With_Box}
    as instantiations
087 Add generic_renaming_       A. Le Guennec  Decl     A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
    declarations parameters to
    Corresponding_Declaration/Body
088 Nil_Element as              S. Rybin       Expr     A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
    Corresponding_Expression_Type
089 What is the same physical   S. Rybin       CU       A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
    CU (compilation unit)
090 Provide additional          D. Cooper      Tech     M    Q  21-May-98 Email
    descriptions for context and
    operations on elements
091 Add additional OOP          B. Pritchett   STD      M    Q  06-May-98 Email
    interfaces to ASIS
092 Unwinding types for         S. Rybin       Expr     A    Q  26-Mar-98 Email
    Corresponding_Expression_Type
093 Nil_Line equal line with    S. Rybin       Text     A    Q  23-Mar-98 Email
    zero length?
094 Default "=" /= Is_Equal?    B. Stanley     STD      M    Q  30-Apr-98 Email
095 Semantic queries for        S. Rybin       STD      A    R  29-Jul-98 Email
    multi-part declarations
096 Normalized associations for S. Rybin       STD      A    R  29 Jul-98 Email
    call-as-dereference and
    dispatching calls
097 Names for components of     S. Rybin       Elem     M    R  29-Jul-98 Email
    derived records
098 Pragma Import as a          S. Rybin       Decl     X       30-Nov-98 Email
    completion of a subprogram
099 A_Formal_Package_Declaration S. Rybin      Decl     X       30-Nov-98 Email
    as an appropriate argument
    for Corresponding_Declaration
100 A_Configuration_Compilation G. Barnes      ASIS     X       30-Nov-98 Email
    Unit_Kind
101 Entries and                 G. Barnes      Decl     X       30-Nov-98 Email
    Correponding_Declaration / Corresponding_Body
102 Generic child units of      G. Barnes      STD      X       17-Dec-98 Email
    generic parents, traversal questions
--- --------------------------- -------------- ------- ---- --- ---------
IS#            Title              Submitter    Section Stat Ver  Action


IS#: Issue Number
Title: Short explanatory title of the issue.
Submitter: Person/group who submitted issue.
    ASISWG   Issue was discussed over the ASIS-Technical
                 and/or ASIS email discussion lists.
    ISO WG9  Issue was initially brought up at an ISO WG9 meeting
Section: Appropriate Clause(s) of the ASIS ISO document.
    Front
    General Clause 1
    Tech    Clause 2 -- Technical Architecture
    ASIS    Clause 3
    Error   Clauses 4 and 5
    Imp     Clauses 6 and 7
    Env     Clauses 8 and 9
    CU      Clauses 10 through 12
    Elem    Clause 13
    Iter    Clause 14
    Decl    Clause 15
    Def     Clause 16
    Expr    Clause 17
    Stmt    Clause 18
    Clause  Clause 19
    Text    Clause 20
    IDs     Clausse 21
    Decomp  Clause 22 and 23 -- Data decomposition
    Gloss   Annex A (Glossary)
    Example Annex B (Examples)
    Appr    Annex C (Miscellaneous Approaches)
    Rat     Annex D (Rationale)
    STD     Applies to multiple sections
Stat: Status may have one of the following letters:
    N  New comment semi-automatically entered into database
    O  Comment Open for review
    M  Comment approved with Modification
    A  Approved or Accepted
    X  Rejected; appropriate rationale also included
    D  Deferred to some later time
    R  Referred to the Toolkit (secondary layer)
Ver: Version suffix for ASIS version 2.0.x that issue was resolved in.
    D  October 1995
    E  November 1995
    F  May 1996
    G  May 1996 for specification (June 1996 ASIS draft Working Draft)
    H  July 1996
    I  October 1996
    J  November 1996
    K  December 1996 (ISO WG9 Technical Ballot)
    L  March 1997
    M  May 1997
    N  June 1997 (ISO WG9 Resolution of Comments)
    P  August 1997 (ISO SC22 CD Registration and CD Final Ballot)
    Q  May 1998 (draft ISO Draft International Standard)
    R  July 1998 (draft Final Draft International Standard)
Action: Date that Status was set/changed in "Stat"

Note: All Technical Issues from #082 to #083 and from #085 through
#093 are a result of the ISO SC22 Ballotting process.  All of these
were submitted with the US ballot.  All approved issues are
incorporated in version 2.0.Q.  After ASIS version 2.0.Q was reviewed,
it was submitted as the Draft International Standard (DIS) for the
Final DIS (FDIS) ballot.  The resulting ASIS version 2.0.R was
submitted as the FDIS to SC22 on 31 July 1998.  During FDIS ballot,
the document was proofed and Issues starting with #098 resulted from
this review.


[Up] [SIGAda] [ACM]

Last update 17 December 1998. Questions, comments to Clyde Roby (CRoby@IDA.Org)